The impact of race relations on NFL attendance: An econometric analysis

Autoři: Nicholas Masafumi Watanabe aff001;  George B. Cunningham aff002
Působiště autorů: University of South Carolina, Columbia, South Carolina, United States of America aff001;  Texas A&M University, TX, United States of America aff002
Vyšlo v časopise: PLoS ONE 15(1)
Kategorie: Research Article
doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0226938


Recent protests by athletes focused on raising awareness of social issues and injustices, such as the Black Lives Matter protests led by Colin Kaepernick of the National Football League’s San Francisco 49ers, have generated a great deal of attention and debate within society. Notably, the protests conducted by these players before games in the 2016 and 2017 seasons became such a sensational topic, that extraordinary amounts of attention was paid to it by the media, consumers, and even politicians who often denounced the players as being unpatriotic. Against this backdrop, the current research examines whether fluctuations in attendance at National Football League games are associated with explicit attitudes towards race, implicit racial prejudice, and racial animus within a population. Specifically, using multiple measures of racial attitudes as part of an econometric model estimating attendance at games, the results suggest that having a higher level of implicit bias in a market leads to a decline in consumer interest in attending games. Additionally, using interaction effects, it is found that while protests generally reduced the negative effects of implicit bias on attendance, markets with lower levels of implicit bias actually had greater declines of attendance during the protests. From this, the current study advances the understanding of racial attitudes and racial animus, and its impact on consumer behavior at the regional level. That is, this research highlights that racial sentiments in a local market were able to predict changes in market behaviors, suggesting that race relations can have wide reaching impacts.

Klíčová slova:

Behavior – Elections – Games – Internet – Metaanalysis – Racial discrimination – Social discrimination – Sports


1. Colin Kaepernick protests anthem over treatment of minorities. The Undefeated. 2016 Aug. Retrieved online:

2. Kasselring C. List of NFL players who protested during the national anthem. Hero Sports. 2017 Sep. Retrieved online:

3. Schoenfeld B. The justice league. Esquire. 2017 Sep. Retrieved online:

4. Casteel K. How do Americans feel about the NFL protests? It depends on how you ask. FiveThirtyEight. 2017 Oct. Retrieved online from:

5. Are Americans Tuning Out the NFL Over Protests? Rasmussen Reports. 2016 Oct. Retrieved online:

6. McClung B. NFL attendance lowest since ‘10 despite Chargers rebound. The Sports Business Daily. 2019 Jan. Retrieved online from:

7. Reid J. Say goodbye to Colin Kaepernick as an NFL player. The Undefeated. 2017 October. Retrieved online:

8. Davis-Young K. Cowboys, Cardinals link arms amid anthem protests. Reuters. 2017. Retrieved online from:

9. Ramsey R. UT/TT poll: Football is popular in Texas. The NFL isn’t. Texas Tribune. 2018 July. Retrieved online from:

10. Neal S. Views of racism as a major problem increases sharply, especially among Democrats. Pew Research Center. 2017 Aug. Retrieved online from:

11. Blair IV, Dasgupta N, Glaser J. Implicit attitudes. In Mikulincer M, Shaver PR, editors. APA handbook of personality and social psychology. Washington DC: American Psychological Association, 2015. p. 665–691.

12. Dovidio J, Kawakami K, Beach K. Implicit and explicit attitudes: Examination of the relationship between measures of inter-group bias. In Brown R Gaertner SL, editors. Blackwell handbook of social psychology: Intergroup processes. Oxford, England: Blackwell, 2001. p. 175–197.

13. Dovidio JF, Kawakami K, Gaertner SL; Implicit and explicit prejudice and interracial interaction. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2002;82: 62–68. doi: 10.1037//0022-3514.82.1.62 11811635

14. Son Hing LS, Chung-Yan GA, Hamilton LK, Zanna MP. two-dimensional model that employs explicit and implicit attitudes to characterize prejudice. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2008;94: 971–987. doi: 10.1037/0022-3514.94.6.971 18505312

15. Stephens-Davidowitz S. The cost of racial animus on a black candidate: Evidence using Google search data. Journal of Public Economics 2014a;118: 26–40.

16. Allport GW. The nature of prejudice. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley. 1954.

17. Crandall CS, Eshleman A, O'Brien L. Social norms and the expression and suppression of prejudice: the struggle for internalization. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2002; 82: 359–378. 11902622

18. Race Relations. Gallup. n.d. Retrieved online from:

19. Schuman H, Steeh C, Bobo L, Krysan M. Racial attitudes in America: Trends and interpretations. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. 1997.

20. Crandall CS, Eshleman A. A justification-suppression model of the expression and experience of prejudice. Psychological Bulletin 2003;129: 414–446. doi: 10.1037/0033-2909.129.3.414 12784937

21. Gaertner SL, Dovidio JF. Reducing intergroup bias: The common ingroup identity model. New York, NY: Routledge. 2000.

22. Barr A, Lane T, Nosenzo D. On the social inappropriateness of discrimination. Journal of Public Economics 2018;164: 153–164.

23. Nuti SV, Wayda B, Ranasinghe I, Wang S, Dreyer RP, Chen SI, et al. The use of google trends in health care research: a systematic review. PloS one, 2014;9: e109583. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0109583 25337815

24. Whitehead AL, Perry SL. Unbuckling the Bible belt: A state-level analysis of religious factors and Google searches for porn. The Journal of Sex Research, 2018;55: 273–283. doi: 10.1080/00224499.2017.1278736 28276941

25. Stephens-Davidowitz S. Everybody lies: Big data, new data, and what the Internet reveals about who we really are. New York, NY: Dey Street Books. 2017.

26. Chae DH, Clouston S, Hatzenbuehler ML, Kramer MR, Cooper HL, Wilson SM, et al. Association between an internet-based measure of area racism and black mortality. PloS one 2015;10: e0122963. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0122963 25909964

27. Chae DH, Clouston S, Martz CD, Hatzenbuehler ML, Cooper HL, Turpin R, et al. Area racism and birth outcomes among Blacks in the United States. Social Science & Medicine 2018;199: 49–55.

28. Pearson AR, Dovidio JF, Gaertner SL. The nature of contemporary prejudice: Insights from aversive racism. Social and Personality Psychology Compass. 2009;3:314–38.

29. Oswald FL, Mitchell G, Blanton H, Jaccard J, Tetlock PE. Predicting ethnic and racial discrimination: A meta-analysis of IAT criterion studies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2013;105(2): 171–192. doi: 10.1037/a0032734 23773046

30. Payne BK, Vuletich HA, Lundberg KB. The bias of crowds: How implicit bias bridges personal and systemic prejudice. Psychological Inquiry 2017a;28(4): 233–248.

31. Payne BK, Vuletich HA, Lundberg KB. Flipping the script on implicit bias research with the bias of crowds. Psychological Inquiry 2017b; 28(4): 306–311.

32. Blanton H, Jaccard J, Klick J, Mellers B, Mitchell G, Tetlock PE. Strong claims and weak evidence: Reassessing the predictive validity of the IAT. Journal of Applied Psychology. 2009;94: 567–582. doi: 10.1037/a0014665 19449998

33. Ditonto TM, Lau RR, Sears DO. AMPing racial attitudes: Comparing the power of explicit and implicit racism measures in 2008. Political Psychology. 2013;34: 487–510.

34. Greenwald AG, Smith CT, Sriram N, Bar‐Anan Y, Nosek BA. Implicit race attitudes predicted vote in the 2008 US presidential election. Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy. 2009b;9: 241–53.

35. Horowitz JM, Livingston G. How Americans view the Black Lives Matter movement. Pew Research Center. 2016 July Retrieved online from:

36. Greenwald AG, Poehlman TA, Uhlmann EL, & Banaji MR. Understanding and using the Implicit Association Test: III. Meta-analysis of predictive validity. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2009a;97: 17–41.

37. Devine PG. Stereotypes and prejudice: Their automatic and controlled components. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 1989;56: 5–18.

38. Hehman E, Flake JK, Calanchini, J. Disproportionate use of lethal force in policing is associated with regional racial biases of residents. Social Psychological and Personality Science 2018;9(4), 393–401.

39. Marini M, Sriram N, Schnabel K, Maliszewski N, Devos T, Ekehammar B, et al. Overweight people have low levels of implicit weight bias, but overweight nations have high levels of implicit weight bias. PLoS One. 2013 Dec 17;8(12):e83543. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0083543 24358291

40. Borland J, MacDonald R. Demand for sport. Oxford Review of Economic Policy. 2003 Dec 1:19: 478–502.

41. Villar JG, Guerrero PR. Sports attendance: a survey of the literature 1973–2007. Rivista di Diritto e di Economia dello Sport 2009;5: 112–151.

42. Jewell RT. The effect of marquee players on sports demand: The case of US Major League Soccer. Journal of Sports Economics. 2017:18: 239–52.

43. Forrest D, Simmons R. Outcome uncertainty and attendance demand in sport: the case of English soccer. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series D (The Statistician). 2002:51: 229–41.

44. Watanabe NM, Yan G, Soebbing BP. Market disruption as a regime for athlete activism: An economic analysis of college football player protests. Sport Management Review. 2018:

45. Falls GA, Natke PA. College football attendance: A panel study of the Football Bowl Subdivision. Applied Economics 2014;46: 1093–1107.

46. Lawson RA, Sheehan K, Stephenson EF. Vend It Like Beckham: David Beckham's Effect on MLS Ticket Sales. International Journal of Sport Finance. 2008:3: 189–175.

47. Ma-Kellams C, Or F, Baek JH, Kawachi I. Rethinking suicide surveillance: Google search data and self-reported suicidality differentially estimate completed suicide risk. Clinical Psychological Science. 2016;4: 480–484.

48. Stephens-Davidowitz S. The data of hate. The New York Times. 2014, July 12. Accessed from:

49. Frantz CM, Cuddy AJC, Burnett M, Ray H, Hart A. A threat in the computer: The Race Implicit Association test as a stereotype threat experience. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 2004;30: 1611–1624. doi: 10.1177/0146167204266650 15536243

50. Greenwald AG, Banaji MR, Nosek BA. Statistically small effects of the Implicit Association Test can have societally large effects. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2015;108: 553–561. doi: 10.1037/pspa0000016 25402677

51. Coates D, Humphreys BR, Zhou L. Reference‐dependent preferences, loss aversion, and live game attendance. Economic Inquiry 2014; 52: 959–973.

52. Yan G, Steller D, Watanabe NM, Popp N. What determines user-generated content creation of college football? A big-data analysis of structural influences. International Journal of Sport Communication, 2018;11: 219–240.

53. Welki AM, Zlatoper TJ. US professional football: The demand for game‐day attendance in 1991. Managerial and Decision Economics, 1994;15: 489–495.

54. Nesbit TM, King KA. The impact of fantasy football participation on NFL attendance. Atlantic Economic Journal 2010;38: 95–108.

55. Welki AM, Zlatoper TJ. US professional football game-day attendance. Atlantic Economic Journal, 1999;27: 285–298.

56. Sung H, Mills BM. Estimation of game-level attendance in major league soccer: Outcome uncertainty and absolute quality considerations. Sport Management Review 2018;21: 519–532.

57. Diehl MA, Drayer J, Maxcy JG. On the demand for live sport contests: Insights from the secondary market for National Football League tickets. 2016;30: 82–94.

58. Bianchi EC, Hall EV, Lee S. Reexamining the Link Between Economic Downturns and Racial Antipathy: Evidence That Prejudice Against Blacks Rises During Recessions. Psychological Science 2018;29: 1584–1597. doi: 10.1177/0956797618777214 30010490

59. Coates D, Humphreys BR. Novelty effects of new facilities on attendance at professional sporting events. Contemporary Economic Policy 2005;23: 436–455.

60. Lucifora C, Simmons R. Superstar effects in sport: Evidence from Italian soccer. Journal of Sports Economics. 2003:4: 35–55.

61. Tainsky S, Winfree JA. Short-run demand and uncertainty of outcome in Major League Baseball. Review of Industrial Organization. 2010:37: 197–214.

62. Drayer J, Rascher DA, McEvoy CD. An examination of underlying consumer demand and sport pricing using secondary market data. Sport Management Review 2012;15: 448–460.

63. Groza MD. NCAA conference realignment and football game day attendance. Managerial and Decision Economics 2010; 31: 517–529.

64. Price DI, Sen KC. The demand for game day attendance in college football: an analysis of the 1997 Division 1‐A season. Managerial and Decision Economics 2003;24: 35–46.

65. Wooldridge JM. Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data. Boston, MA: MIT press. 2010.

66. Huang H, Humphreys BR. Sports participation and happiness: Evidence from US microdata. Journal of Economic Psychology 2012;33: 776–793.

67. Stock JH, Watson MW. Heteroskedasticity-robust standard errors for fixed effects panel data regression. Econometrica 2008;76: 155–174.

68. Cameron AC, Trivedi PK. Microeconometrics. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. 2008.

69. Williams R. Using the margins command to estimate and interpret adjusted predictions and marginal effects. The Stata Journal. 2012;12:308–331.

70. Cohen J. Multiple regression as a general data-analytic system. Psychological bulletin. 1968;70: 426–443.

71. Richardson JT. Eta squared and partial eta squared as measures of effect size in educational research. Educational Research Review. 2011;6: 135–47.

72. Cohen J. Eta-squared and partial eta-squared in fixed factor ANOVA designs. Educational and psychological measurement. 1973;33: 107–12.

73. Fritz CO, Morris PE, Richler JJ. Effect size estimates: current use, calculations, and interpretation. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. 2012;141: 2–18.

74. Humphreys BR, Mondello M. Franchise values in North American professional sports leagues: Evidence from the repeat sales method. International Journal of Sport Finance. 2008:3: 98–105.

75. Zygmont ZX, Leadley JC. When is the honeymoon over? Major League Baseball attendance 1970–2000. Journal of Sport Management. 2005:19: 278–99.

76. Lebrecht S, Pierce LJ, Tarr MJ, Tanaka JW. Perceptual other-race training reduces implicit racial bias. 2009;PloS one 4: e4215. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0004215 19156226

77. Ziegert JC, Hanges PJ. Employment discrimination: the role of implicit attitudes, motivation, and a climate for racial bias. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2005;90: 553–562. doi: 10.1037/0021-9010.90.3.553 15910149

78. Chan J. The effect of college education on intolerance: evidence from Google search data. Applied Economics Letters. 2019:26: 83–86.

79. Connor P, Sarafidis V, Zyphur MJ, Keltner D, Chen S. Income Inequality and White-on-Black Racial Bias in the United States: Evidence From Project Implicit and Google Trends. Psychological science. 2019:30: 205–22. doi: 10.1177/0956797618815441 30633654

80. Bokelmann B, Lessmann S. Spurious patterns in Google Trends data–An analysis of the effects on tourism demand forecasting in Germany. Tourism Management. 2019; 75: 1–12.

81. King BG. The tactical disruptiveness of social movements: Sources of market and mediated disruption in corporate boycotts. Social Problems, 2011;58: 491–517.

82. King BG, Pearce NA. The contentiousness of markets: Politics, social movements, and institutional change in markets. Annual Review of Sociology 2010;36: 249–267.

83. McDonnell MH, Werner T. Blacklisted businesses: Social activists’ challenges and the disruption of corporate political activity. Administrative Science Quarterly, 2016; 61: 584–620.

84. Cunningham GB. Diversity and inclusion in sport organizations: A multilevel perspective. 4th ed. New York: Routledge; 2019.

85. Fink JS, Pastore DL. Diversity in sport? Utilizing the business literature to devise a comprehensive framework of diversity initiatives. Quest 1999;51: 310–327.

86. Steward AD, Cunningham GB. Racial identity and its impact on job applicants. Journal of Sport Management 2015;29: 245–256.

87. Cunningham GB, Fink JS. Diversity issues in sport and leisure. Journal of Sport Management, 2006;20: 455–465.

88. Cunningham GB, Dixon MA, Singer JN, Oshiro KF, Ahn NY, Weems A. A Site to Resist and Persist: Diversity, Social Justice, and the Unique Nature of Sport. Journal of Global Sport Management. In press; 1–9.

89. Doherty AJ, Chelladurai P. Managing cultural diversity in sport organizations: A theoretical perspective. Journal of Sport Management, 1999;13: 280–297.

90. Kanazawa MT, Funk JP. Racial discrimination in professional basketball: Evidence from Nielsen ratings. Economic Inquiry 2001;39: 599–608.

91. Araos C. NYCFC fans troubled by a violent, far-right fringe attending matches. The Athletic. 2018 Nov 1. Retrieved online:

92. Silverman R. How New York City soccer fans are fighting facism in the stands. The Huffington Post. 2019 March 1. Retrieved online:

93. Ioanes E. Major League Soccer has a far-right problem. The Daily Dot. 2019 March 6. Retrieved from:

94. Watanabe NM, Yan G, Soebbing BP, Pegoraro A. Is there economic discrimination on sport social media? An analysis of Major League Baseball. Journal of Sport Management, 2017;31: 374–386.

Článek vyšel v časopise


2020 Číslo 1